MAO’S GHOST HAUNTS CHINA’S 60TH BIRTHDAY
New York September 28, 2009
With world attention focused this week on the phony `missile crisis’ with Iran and Germany’s dull as sauerkraut election, China’s upcoming birthday bash has so far been largely ignored. We should pay attention to this very important event.
 
 October 1st marks the 60th anniversary of the founding of the People’s Republic of China.   Beijing’s mammoth birthday fete will include China’s largest ever military parade showcasing new  weapons, and an Olympic-size gala.  Ninety percent of the weapons to be shown are said to never before have been shown in public.
 
With typical Communist Party grandiosity, efforts are even being made to improve Beijing’s weather.
 
Off in Washington, party pooper US Defense Secretary Robert Gates just warned China’s growing military power `threatens our freedom of movement and narrows our strategic options.’   Translation: the US Seventh Fleet can no longer operate with impunity off China’s coast or be certain of defending Taiwan from a Chinese invasion.   
 
China is reasserting its historic sovereignty. It seems inevitable that China  will relentlessly push US power back into the Pacific. But this strategic development became inevitably with the return of China to the major power status it had enjoyed until 1800, when this great nation fell into a grim era of self-isolation, political weakness, and revolution.  
 
I first came to China in 1975 during the madness of the Great Cultural Revolution. During my travels across China over the ensuing three decades, I saw China transformed from a giant, dimly-lit prison camp into today’s booming nation, which just surpassed Japan to become the world’s second largest economy. 
 
This is the most remarkable event I have seen in my life.
 
Much of the credit goes to China’s late leader,  Deng Xiaoping, one of the  20th century’s greatest men. He ended Marxist dogma, releasing the energy of his long-suffering people whose nation had been raped by western and Japanese imperialism, then ravaged by brutal civil wars and destructive Marxist policies.     
 
But a ghost will haunt this celebration: the Great Helmsman, Mao Zedong. What to make of him? 
 
I have long struggled to understand Mao. Was he modern history’s greatest revolutionary and an earth-shaker, or a demented mass murderer who nearly destroyed China, as his critics claim? 
 
Great times produce great men. Mao rose from the chaos of 1920’s China to lead the newfound Communist Party. He fought Chiang Kai-shek’s Nationalists, an assortment of powerful regional warlords, and, later, Japanese invaders.    
China suffered some 15-20 million dead from 1928-1949.  
 
Mao was an accomplished poet, writer and historian, a profound thinker, and a superb military strategist. His works on guerilla war sit on my desk.   Mao crushed the US-backed Nationalist’s 4.3-million strong armies in a series of  titanic battles.
 
Mao gave the Communists political and strategic direction. Aiding him were a group of outstanding generals – the `Ten Marshals’ – among them Zhu De, Lin Piao, Peng Dehui, Chen Yi and Nie Rongzhen – who crushed Chiang Kai-shek’s armies.    Most westerners know nothing about China’s epic eight-year struggle against Japan, or its long civil war.  
 
The Great Helmsman united fractured, war-torn China for the first time in centuries, restoring its pride and self-confidence after two centuries of humiliation.  Mao thwarted both Soviet and US efforts to turn China into a client state, and built up China’s military power.
 
But Mao’s crackpot economic notions, notably the infamous 1958 Great Leap Forward, created famines that killed 20-36 million Chinese peasants.  `Red Emperor’ Mao was prodigal with his people’s lives, and, according to aides who were close to him,  was shockingly indifferent to their suffering. Many senior officials worried about the deification of Mao and its effects upon the Great Helmsman. 
 
Mao horrified even brutal Soviet leaders by saying he was prepared to lose half his people to emerge victorious from a nuclear war.  
 
When the Communist Party resisted Mao, he tried to destroy it by unleashing the Great Cultural Revolution. China was plunged into chaos and civil war. China’s brilliant, much under-rated premier, Zhou Enlai, curbed some of Mao’s worst excesses, thwarted the party’s hard left,  and rescued China by engineering Deng Xiaoping into power.    
 
Deng crushed die-hard Maoists known as the Gang of Four, and restored order.  His sweeping economic reforms revitalized China, unleashing its latent economic power.    But Deng’s great achievements – and this week’s huge birthday party in Beijing - would not have been possible without Mao’s unification of China and imposition of an all-powerful one-party state.
 
So, as with many Chinese, I’m uncertain how to qualify Chairman Mao. I stand in awe of his achievements and brilliance, but cannot forget the suffering he inflicted on China.  
 
Like Stalin – once called `half man, half beast’ -  Mao appealed as much as he repelled. Most Chinese now regard Mao as their nation’s beloved, respected father -but who went dangerously senile before his death in 1976. The egos of old dictators and kings can be very dangerous.   
 
I suspect as time goes by, Mao’s misdeeds, like Stalin’s,  will fade away and he will again be glorified as China’s greatest modern ruler. The glowing image of the Great Helmsman will continue to hang over the gate of the Beijing’s Forbidden City.
China will continue its real Great Leap Forward.
 
 
copyright Eric S. Margolis 2009      
 
 
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
              
cleesburg
Monday, September 28, 2009 2:45 PM
Eric, great and fair writing! I'd say that, in terms of trying to restore China back to its historical place as a civilization and a nation-state, Mao and Deng are real comrades with the same goal, only differ in approaches.
TMK
Monday, September 28, 2009 4:03 PM
Eric,
I don't think Chinese people are happy with the China's state of negligence towards its people.
Dik
Monday, September 28, 2009 6:41 PM
I recall the late 1960's and the Chairman's Little Red Book... a lot of my classmates made jest of the Chinese reading this... overlooking the most important thing... They were reading.
Stormcrow
Tuesday, September 29, 2009 9:28 AM
China's biggest revolutions are yet to come. A massive population that requires excess resources and is, to put it simply, at its weakest within. While it holds significant US treasury reserves, a spike in inflation would be catastrophic, hence the reason why it's buying commodities now and setting them in reserve. The Uighur activity earlier this year saw an incredibly quick armed response, as did Tibet the year before. They know the situation is tenuous and survival of the reigning political order (their style of government defies easy description now) rests quick and massive centralized action. Social movements are like grass fires in that they spread quickly and burn fast; perhaps no other country knows this better than China.
Hoffman
Wednesday, September 30, 2009 4:20 AM
In general today, Mao is held in high esteem by the vast majority of Chinese living in the Mainland - both young and old. Not that they feel he is without blemishes cause they understand that not everything he did was successful. But, what he did, which no one else had managed to do in 150 years was unite China again and bring some pride back into being Chinese. And the Chinese have an attitude that what's a few million or few dozen million lives when the motherland is at stake. My 20 years living in China has shown me that the Chinese are a fiercely nationalist and proud people and they support their system and they support their leadership. The Great Helmsman will undoubtedly go down in Chinese history one of the most important leaders in China's history and the father of modern China.
Budspy
Wednesday, September 30, 2009 1:13 PM
China has Mao, Russia has Stalin, post-WWI Germany had Hitler ... all monsters to be sure, but they all gave their people 'their pride back'. It cost millions to be sure, but was it 'worth it?' That's like asking if building the American Republic was worth the generations of enslaved Africans, millions of betrayed and dead Natives, a Civil War that killed over 600k, and the exploitation of new immigrants in mines, sweatshops and railroads.
Ibram
Thursday, October 01, 2009 12:04 PM
An excellent and recent book on Mau and his legacy is Mau: The Untold Story by Jung Chang. It desconstructs many mythes about him, particularly his military genius. Granted he is still a titan in history, but many of his successes against the nationalists were thanks to his complete ruthlessness. The book covers the entirety of Mau's life and is a stunning read. I recommend it to any history/chinese culture buffs. The way he played the Russians off against the Americans was masterful.
DoDaCanaDa
Friday, October 02, 2009 11:58 PM
Another incise and informative piece, Eric. I would love to visit China. Being one of 35 million Canadians along side 305 million Americans and used to wide open spaces, it´s hard to visualize a country with 1,306,000,000 people having general stability and improving living standards. They must be doing something right.

It´ a great irony of history when you think about it. Who would have imagined so many years ago, the Communists would end up with the cash, and the Capitalists have the debt to pay with a declining standard of living?

America is becoming much more fractious just when a common purpose short of a war is demanded by the Times.

There are currently 8 comments
Comments Commentaries
Currently Ordered By:
Commentaries by Category